Elevate Your Thanksgiving Dessert Game with Hilly’s Pumpkin Caramel Pie

When it comes to Thanksgiving desserts, pumpkin pie is a classic, but let’s be honest, it can sometimes be a bit predictable. Jack Roskopp, Digital Content Editor at Graham Media Group, stumbled upon a game-changing recipe that transforms the ordinary into the extraordinary.

The recipe hails from the renowned Milk Bar, known for turning simple bakes into indulgent delights. Named “Hilly’s Pumpkin Caramel Pie,” this dessert promises to redefine your Thanksgiving experience.

The journey begins with a traditional pie crust, and if you have a tried-and-true recipe, stick with it. What sets this pie apart is the homemade caramel base. Despite initial nerves about making caramel without a candy thermometer, the process is surprisingly easy, yielding a delectable salted caramel layer that adds depth to every bite.

The next layer introduces a white chocolate pumpkin ganache. Roasting the pumpkin puree and combining it with white chocolate ganache might raise eyebrows, but according to Jack, the combination is surprisingly delightful. The result is a creamy and flavorful layer that complements the caramel.

A classic whipped cream layer follows, essential for balancing the sweetness of the ganache. Unlike the typical dollop on a slice, this recipe incorporates the whipped cream as a third layer, ensuring a perfect harmony of flavors.

To crown the creation, a homemade streusel crumb topping adds texture—crunchy, chewy, and a hint of creamy. Jack expresses amazement at the ease of making streusel and contemplates using it to enhance all future desserts.

While acknowledging the multiple steps involved, Jack assures that the finished product is well worth the effort. Having impressed friends at a recent Friendsgiving, he anticipates making it the star of his family’s Thanksgiving.

If you’re looking to make a splash in the dessert department this Thanksgiving, consider taking on the challenge of crafting Hilly’s Pumpkin Caramel Pie. The layers and flavors promise a culinary adventure that might just make you the hero of the day.